by liberal japonicus
As Jon Stewart labelled it, most of us have probably been gloat-scrolling, but the next question is what happens now. The media, in typical fashion, has pushed for a yes-no answer to ‘will you impeach the president’, trying to flatten what needs to be a multi-front strategy to a single question. I’m pretty sure no journalist was asking FDR ‘what are your plans for Adolf Hitler’ and at any rate, this seems a lot more like 1942 than 1945.
So I’ve got a bit of an allergy to all these people weighing in on what the Dems should do. I actually think that trying to pluck and pulp the lowest hanging fruit while slowly moving up the tree would be best. I know the Hagseth impeachment was put forward by Massie, and I wonder if in the new year, other republicans would be willing to put forward similar motions, but I’m heartened by the fact that the current Republican leadership is doing everything to try and stop it, which I hope will redound to them. I wonder if the Dems could simply refuse to pass any budget appropriations relating to defense while Hegseth is still secretary of Defense. Only the House can impeach, and I doubt there will be any house republicans who would do what Massie is doing, so I wonder how other impeachment attempts should be handled. Targeting Jared Kushner and Witkoff might be one avenue, or dragging Elon Musk and his minions to unpack the DOGE disaster might be another.
Targeted prosecutions and reinforced laws about stock-trading and congressional insider trading might be another place to start. Or bringing ICE to heel, which might have Miller overextend himself and wear out what has to be a pretty short leash.
However, if someone has a better idea, I’m all ears. My feeling is that if a thread can be found to pull on, it could unravel a lot.
My beef with Jeffries is his meeting with Jarred Kushner. He seems to have wanted to keep it quiet. When it was reported anyway, he offered a rationale so lame (“we discussed affordability issues”) that it insults my intelligence. His lieutenant, Katherine Clark, is my Representative. She will not stop hearing from me about that meeting, for whatever that’s worth. Maybe Speaker Jeffries will shape up, maybe not.
My beef with Schumer is the kabuki he has played over and over: justifying cave-ins to the Republicons by extracting “promises” from the likes of Yertl. His surrender on the Big Ugly Bill by allowing 8 carefully selected Dems to vote for cloture still sticks in my craw. If he did that simply to forestall the Republicons abolishing the filibuster, there’s no way he will let his Dems abolish it either.
Neither of these guys has what it takes to deMAGAfy the government, but you go to the mattresses with the capos you’ve got, not the capos you wish you had, and hope the button men you elected have the balls to actually fight.
–TP
“The Devil has shown in the past that he is more than capable in the role and I have no doubt he will do a great job,” said Senator Chuck Schumer. “He knows what we Democrats are trying to accomplish in this new Congress and I can’t think of anyone better to set our legislative calendar.”
Satan Once Again Favored To Emerge As Senate Majority Leader
Surprise, surprise! Before the link, the headline:
Trump bought Nvidia stock as he helped chipmaker with change to export rulePresident purchased up to $5m of stock before revoking Biden-era rule that limited Nvidia’s ability to sell to China
https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2026/nov/13/trump-nvidia-stock-jensen-huang-us-china
I know I’m peculiar, but I still believe geographic diversity matters. I’ve been quietly concerned that our House and Senate leaders were both from Brooklyn. I’m inclined to be less quiet about it now that they’re going to be (probably) Speaker and Senate Majority Leader. I don’t trust them as the face of the party.
I don’t trust them to try to rein in the finance industry that is busily blowing another massive bubble. I don’t trust them to deal with public lands. They’re from a state whose voting system is… not a model for reform. To hairshirt’s point, two guys from Brooklyn are <i>not</i> who I want out front for the next 18 months convincing America to vote <i>for</i> Democrats, not just <i>against</i> Republicans.
My North Star is fixing the filibuster. They don’t have to eliminate it, but they have to do something. There were proposals for a sliding filibuster, so that the first vote to invoke cloture needed 60, but after a set period, that dropped to a smaller number and finally, step by step, got to a simple majority or alternatively, a positive filibuster, where they had to vote to continue debate, putting people on the record. Unfortunately, according to this LGM post that cite Josh Marshall, it looks like no one, not even Sanders et al, want to do anything.
Re: geographic diversity
Totally agree. Of course, one problem is that “leadership” positions generally require some “seniority” (to gain the needed experience, and know where the levers are, if nothing else), and that’s much easier to manage for politicians from parts of the country that have been reliably “blue” for a long time.
Not sure that “MD” is much better than NY for the kind of diversity you want.
Got any Senators from Western states that you have in mind? IIRC, CA “aged out” a couple of Senators in the past decade or so, so while reliably blue, not sufficiently old-farty to take over running the Old Boys Club.
I think the minimum fix (I emphasize minimum) is to return to the talking filibuster. No more easy “we’ll filibuster” and the bill gets dropped. You gotta stand up and talk. And everybody knows who is driving it (vs just going along with the party crowd), because they’re the ones talking.
I think the minimum fix (I emphasize minimum) is to return to the talking filibuster.
We got the current arrangement after the Dixiecrats demonstrated that they could tag-team members of the group in (I yield the floor to the gentleman from South Carolina) and keep talking for weeks/months. The radical change was creating the two-track system: while one track was filibustered the other track could move forward on all of the small but important and not-controversial items that the talking filibuster put on hold. Once the two-track system was in place, the change to the non-talking filibuster was trivial.
It’s not the talking filibuster that you really want to bring back. It’s the one-track system where the talking filibuster brings all other business in the Senate to a halt. No taking up another bill, no confirmation votes, no consideration of House amendments to a bill already passed… Those are the price that got enough Senators to vote for cloture to kill a talking filibuster.
and that’s much easier to manage for politicians from parts of the country that have been reliably “blue” for a long time.
Not that many years ago we had Pelosi (CA) and Reid (NV). At the time I commented that the Northeast Democratic Mafia would never let that happen again; they would rather be a rump regional party than concede floor control to the West or Midwest again. Murray (WA) and Wyden (OR) both have more time in the Senate than Schumer. There are lots of House members from different parts of the country with more time than Jeffries.
Hitler spoke:
“You all know what a volt is and an ampere, don’t you?” Hitler said to the assembled crowd. “But do you know what a goebbels, a goering are? A goebbels is the amount of nonsense a man speaks in an hour and a goering is the amount of metal that can be pinned on a man’s breast.”
Hat tip, the Atlantic.
A goebbels in American electrical parlance is a miller, and a goering is a hegseth.
Surely that should be a trump. A miller would be the amount of bile one person can spew in an hour.
This is still on what to do, so I reckon it belongs here rather than the new open thread.
https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2026/nov/14/corporate-democrats-identity-politics-progressives
Goebbels would be appalled to be compared to His Orangeness. Lies and untruths are not the same as nonsense, and the minister for enlightenment of the people and propaganda never slipped into incoherence. I do not know enough about looks-like-Nosferatu’s rhetoric skills to make an informed comparison but my bet would be on the clubfooted poison dwarf being superior there.
I don’t know whether this should go in the Open Thread, or here. It’s headlined:
Nate Silver’s Unscientific, Totally Subjective Breakdown of the Democrats’ Future Stars
I found it interesting, here is a gift link for anyone else who might
https://www.nytimes.com/2026/11/15/opinion/nate-silver-democrats-midterms-president.html?unlocked_article_code=1.Q1E.s1VH.BNMETEZnohxS&smid=url-share
Re: Nate Silver – I’d put Newsom a step further to the right than Silver does, and Buttigieg a step further to the left. Pritzger and Warnock are both further left than is Newsom. I think Harris is more of a fighter than he gives her credit for as well.
Hmm, maybe he just doesn’t get Californians very well.
I’m glad to get your input, nous. I pay a certain amount of attention to Nate Silver, but (as we have seen in the past) he has blind spots. Below is the latest from Brian Beutler, FWIW. As always, I have had to disable links:
Off Message
EXCLUSIVE: Democrats’ Lawful Answer To Project 2025
Obama and Biden administration veterans are taking aim at the culture of over-caution that’s hamstrung liberal government, with a new plan that’ll allow Dems to rebuild after Trump: fast, and legally.
Brian Beutler
A new project, spearheaded by veterans of the Obama and Biden administrations, should hearten those of us who are concerned the Democratic Party will return to power in 2029 unprepared to build a functioning government atop the wreckage of the Trump regime.
These experts, affiliated with the Center for Law and Public Trust, aim to upend the governing culture within the Democratic establishment, in part by rethinking how key appointees conceive of their roles. They hope to help the next Democratic administration make early headway on everything from hiring and firing decisions to delivery of public benefits, and do so faster and more efficiently than predecessor administrations. All without requiring new action from Congress.
“There’s going to be 100 policy nuclear bombs on everyone’s lap,” explained Seth Frotman, who served as general counsel for the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau in the Biden administration. “Understanding what the administration’s goals and objectives are when it comes to [post-Trump reconstruction] are going to be so incredibly important day one.”
The bottlenecks these former officials hope to clear are largely self-imposed. They’re byproducts of a culture of over-caution within the realm of elite law, where Democratic administrations often recruit general counsels, who in turn advise cabinet secretaries and other agency heads.
In a new publication, obtained exclusively by Off Message, Frotman along with coauthors Sam Bagenstos, Amy Marshak, and Karl Thompson reimagine the role played by lawyers—counsels for department and agency heads—who, in past administrations, have frequently steered policymakers away from swift, decisive, or creative action.
Best Practices For Federal Agency General Counsels
1.13MB ∙ PDF file
Download
[I did not download this, because I don’t have a subscription to
Brian Beutler’s Off Message. I’m assuming/hoping he won’t mind me posting the contents of the open messages to others, on the grounds that it might publicise his work to other possible interested parties.]
That’s a problem when the public demands responsive government, and when Democratic voters expect rapid reversal of Trump-era abuses.
Governing failure arises from unimaginative or risk-averse leadership, as often as it does from overreaching ambition or incompetence. The Democratic Party as a whole is shot through with professional-services providers like lawyers, consultants, pollsters, and crisis communicators who are habituated to discouraging creative approaches to solving problems. Many of them view protecting clients from controversy as their top priority, even if that means governing objectives slow or stall out as collateral damage. This helps explain everything from the tepid rhetoric of elected officials to the poll-tested agendas candidates tout on the campaign trail. But it also affects the hidden, deliberative processes of senior policymakers, which can foster unnecessary paralysis.
The hope is to get these policymakers and their advisers thinking more seriously, as Bagenstos puts it, about “the opportunity cost of doing nothing.”
“If the general counsel understands their job as identifying—and protecting the agency from—legal risk, rather than lawfully advancing the agency’s and administration’s goals, they are likely to err on the side of conservatism and inaction in their advice,” the report reads. “The prospect of a loss in court, an adverse Government Accountability Office (GAO) finding, or a well-publicized oversight hearing can loom large for lawyers advising on agency action, but the downsides of failing to take a particular action are often much more diffuse, and far less apt to result in blame. This conservative bias can manifest itself in different ways: OGC attorneys may perceive their job as identifying every possible legal risk, without assessing how likely or how harmful those risks might be. Or they may see their role as identifying the ‘correct’ interpretation of a statute or regulation (even when courts have not identified any such answer), and thus treat any other interpretation, even ones on which reasonable minds could disagree, as wrong. Or OGC attorneys may engage with agency staff in multiple rounds of discussion, wordsmithing, and revision in a quest to reduce risk without driving toward a decision point—all the while losing sight of the ultimate goal of the document on which they are advising.”
In an interview, Frotman cited an illustrative example: “For the better part of my entire adult fucking life, I have been trying to simply get the Department of Defense to tell the Department of Education all of the people who are eligible to have their student loans forgiven because they have served our country in uniform, often at great danger to themselves, for 10 years. And we were simply unable to literally transfer the data from the Department of Defense to the right people and the right companies at [the Department of Education] to basically cancel their loans.”
The impediment isn’t black-letter law, but the existence of litigation risk, and federal counterparties who act to protect their principals, rather than to advance core policy goals. This has hindered relief not just to military service members, but to all manner of borrowers who are eligible for loan forgiveness by dint of their lengthy public service. “There was Privacy Act risk,” they’d argue, “in sharing government information…. We literally have let billions of dollars for hundreds of thousands, if not millions, of people continue into the Linda McMahon regime because, at every turn, someone argued that this was not allowed under the law. This was something that we couldn’t do. It’s crazy.”
The new rollout—the latest in a multifaceted effort to prepare Democrats for the governing challenges that await them—is a first step toward superseding the culture of conservatism that runs through the Democratic Party’s professional class.
According to Bagenstos, a University of Michigan Law professor and former general counsel to both the Department of Health and Human Services and Office of Management and Budget, the project will entail trainings and the building of talent pipelines, to ensure that public servants with proactive and creative mindsets are primed to collaborate with each other across government in a new administration.
This and other parallel projects stand in welcome contrast to the Washington-based efforts of party actors to influence or control the future policy direction of the Democratic Party.
When Donald Trump became president for the second time, and his appointees began implementing the GOP’s “Project 2025” plan to kneecap the administrative state, it changed grassroots Democrats’ expectations of how their leaders should govern in the future. Across the party, operatives began to ask themselves what the Democratic answer to Project 2025 would look like. The approaches that have received the most media attention have been disappointingly conventional: think-tank products; legislative proposals that differ little from the agenda items on just about every Democratic presidential candidate platform since 2008.
Policy reform has its place, of course, but it is not an answer to the havoc of DOGE and Project 2025—neither as a countervailing assertion of power, nor as an approach to post-Trump reconstruction that can operate at the speed of U.S. elections. Waiting for Congress to fix the government is a recipe for yet more governing failure, and a political pendulum swing back toward the GOP.
Amid the abject failure of the Trump administration, though, punditry has begun to treat the very concept of move-fast administrative governing as a self-defeating proposition—DOGE as a cautionary tale for activists of all ideological stripes. Critics argue, in essence, for Democrats not to respond to GOP sabotage with a countervailing surge of activist government. But that would place the party out of step with its own voters, and, crucially, it would leave Democratic appointees overwhelmed by the basic challenge of fixing the vandalized government they’ll inherit if they win the 2028 election.
This is not “DOGE, but progressive.”
For starters, the problem these former officials aim to fix is but one component of a much larger challenge. Reviving government capacity as fast as Republicans destroyed it will likely require reforms to all three branches of government. A change in executive-branch culture that greases the skids for administrative action will be helpful on its own, but its potential will be limited if new legislation can be filibustered, or if this Supreme Court remains the partisan-but-final word on existing statutory authority.
It’s also meant to be responsive to democratic demand—a novel synthesis that proposes to alleviate public discontent with sclerotic federal institutions, without lapsing into the illegality and carelessness of the GOP approach: rash firings, abrupt policy change, opaque hierarchies of authority.
The Trump-Project 2025 proposition was, in effect, that the American government can drive big and rapid change, but only through lawbreaking and authoritarian management. These new best practices are rooted in the belief that democratic government can be nimble and responsive in lawful ways.
That, the authors hope, will provide some insurance against the risk that the electorate will try its luck with another authoritarian regime in the future.
One of the reasons voters gave Trump a second chance, Frotman argues, “was that they didn’t think the government was doing enough to actually help their lives.” The consequences have been tragic, but they militate for this middle ground. “In addition to this idea of, like, how do you rein in the just massive overreach, the flip side of that is: how do you actually make sure government delivers so that people…want to elect a government that abides by the law, that they trust is actually trying to solve their problems.”
.