State of the Discussion

The posts in play...

An open thread on July 4th
(166)
+
Plus ça change…
(16)
+
From the Chinatalk substack
(21)
+
 

The comments...

novakant
+ I have to admit that I only remember Paul McCartney secretly rerecording Ringo's drum track in the studio at night - is that true? And [. . .]
russell
+ The other player that comes to mind for me right away with this trait is John Paul Jones. Jones was the glue in Zep. And [. . .]
nous
+ The people who downplay Ringo's drumming are the same people who go on about how Jimmy Page was a sloppy, overrated guitarist, and probably the [. . .]
Michael Cain
+ A personal hero, on a few levels. A friend once remarked that the only measure of a drummer's contribution to music was their technical virtuosity. "Yeah?" [. . .]
russell
+ Hey, open thread!! Ringo Starr, aka Sir Richard Starkey, turns 85 today. The most musical drummer on the planet, his drum fills are melodies. [. . .]
CharlesWT
+ Charles, your link to Grok's discussion of Alien Space Bats in Fiction is the only AI link of yours I've ever found useful or entertaining. My [. . .]
GftNC
+ Charles, your link to Grok's discussion of Alien Space Bats in Fiction is the only AI link of yours I've ever found useful or entertaining. [. . .]
Snarki, child of Loki

Please expand on any memories of what the alien space bats commenter was up to.
WE CAN'T STOP HERE
THIS IS BAT COUNTRY

Pro Bono

"Expected" by who?
I might have expressed myself more precisely. I was merely discussing what I'm interested in reading.

Hartmut
+ It seems that they - being more robust - needed more high quality calories than our own ancestors and that the really lean times came [. . .]
liberal japonicus
+ wj's comment reminds me of Ena Matsuoka, a member of Japanese girl idol group https://www.scmp.com/week-asia/people/article/3052704/japanese-sex-pest-jailed-stalking-pop-idol-ena-matsuoka-using A Japanese man has been sentenced to 30 months in prison for [. . .]
liberal japonicus
+ Hartmut, sorry, I dropped in and saw your post, but thought one had been freed. I think we put a textblock on He of the [. . .]
wj
+ It's long been pretty clear that the Neanderthals were every bit as intelligent, and culturally complex, as homo sapiens. Just earlier. And were [. . .]
wj
+ I've long since resigned myself to the reality that anything and everything that I have ever written on the Internet is available to someone willing [. . .]
Hartmut
+ And for the third time my short post disappeared. I only answered a question from russell concerning a former poster and whether anyone remembers him (yes) [. . .]
liberal japonicus
+ About what topics get people's dander up, I'd go to Martin Luther's observation that "Most human affairs come down to depending upon whose ox is [. . .]
CharlesWT

I've encountered ASB scenarios in some of the SF/F I've read, but don't remember such scenarios ever being described as ASBs.
Alien Space Bats in Fiction

GftNC

Perversely, I feel a sense of loss....

russell
+ Nothing in a context suggesting alien space bats. Time to adjust my meds. :) Before I began commenting here, I hung out at RedState for a [. . .]
Tony P.
+ Pro Bono: I see no problem with discussing religious perspectives, so long as we're not expected to follow arguments from scriptural authority. "Expected" by who? [. . .]
Michael Cain
+ and I pulled all of the site's content out the hard way... I've mentioned that I have wound up as the extended families' archivist, and have [. . .]
wonkie
+ I think that the diversity--meaning the self-defined conservative voices---lessened because they simply couldn't justify their positions. This is a very smart, well-informed, articulate group of [. . .]
Michael Cain
+ I've tried searching the blog many times for all possible variations of "alien space bat". No joy. From back at the time when it looked like [. . .]
GftNC
+ lj, I wondered whether you'd pick up the manipulation v pulling the strings aspect, but I decided not to go there with you given how [. . .]
CharlesWT

Well, since I've collected most everyone else's birthdate or approximate age, my birthdate is 11/14/47.

liberal japonicus
+ A couple of observations. I'm probably a/the fly in the ointment. I'm happy to discuss things, but I am pretty big on examining unexamined assumptions. [. . .]
wj

It's also possible that I hallucinated the whole thing.
Nah. More likely the alien space bats purged it.

Hartmut

I just posted twice but after refreshing the post disappeared each time .

GftNC

It's also possible that I hallucinated the whole thing
LOL
And I'm quite willing to read rational arguments for Trumpism, if any exist.
To quote the Spartans: "if".

Pro Bono
+ How much diversity are you, personally, willing to tolerate? Anyone who's willing to engage in reasoned, fact-based, and tolerably polite discussion. I see no problem with discussing [. . .]
russell
+ russell, please stop taunting me with the alien space bats guy. I've tried searching the blog many times for all possible variations of "alien space bat". [. . .]
wj
+ conversations with them tend to devolve into unanswerable arguments from authority. I.e., if "the Bible says" is not part of your epistemology, there isn't really [. . .]
GftNC
+ russell, please stop taunting me with the alien space bats guy. You've done it before; he was before my time, and I am deeply [. . .]
GftNC
+ Yeah, I can't imagine it working with seriously MAGA types, or religious fundamentalists, essentially because I can't see that either of those groups are concerned [. . .]
russell
+ More seriously: How much diversity are you, personally, willing to tolerate? tl;dr - anybody sensible, for any reasonable definition of "sensible", is probably OK with me. I'm [. . .]
russell

Yes, I realize that I'm assuming a general preference for reality. Challenge that if you wish.
bring back alien space bats guy! :)

wj
+ For those who would like to see a greater diversity of views here (diversity! What a concept!), it might be useful to ask a couple [. . .]
rdldot
+ lj, thanks for the link to the original post. I have been a perennial lurker since the days of Moe but I didn't know [. . .]
GftNC

The discussions here are unique, and greatly appreciated.
Hard agree.
And bobbyp, FWIW, you have never angered me.

bobbyp
+ What a long strange trip it's been. Indeed. My apologies to all for angering you at one time or another over the course of the [. . .]
novakant
+ Hilzoy, Katherine (who did pro bono work for detainees) and Publius who probably wouldn't be put in a Iraq war hawk box These three were definitely [. . .]
liberal japonicus

And going forward from that post, the three original bloggers here were Moe Lane, Katherine and von.

liberal japonicus
+ If you are talking about the original crew, that was before my time, but we had Hilzoy, Katherine (who did pro bono work for detainees) [. . .]
CaseyL
+ novakant: "But let's also remember that the good old days were those of the wars in Iraq, Afghanistan and Libya. " I think that's when the split [. . .]
liberal japonicus
+ LOL. I guess there's a reason the Hippocratic oath is supposed to start with 'first do no harm' (a wikipedia check says it ain't so Although [. . .]
Michael Cain
+ So it's entirely possible for a very wealthy person to prefer a weekend's leisure to another million dollars. But would they prefer a person in Flint [. . .]
liberal japonicus
+ I actually miss most of the commenters who have been banned during my roughly 2 decades here. Does anybody have the full list? I don't have [. . .]
russell
+ I'm a 13-year-old shiba inu raised by a murder of crows... LOL I'm a 68 year old American geezer raised on duck and cover, Kennedy assassinations, Vietnam, [. . .]