Open Thread

This in today from Brian Beutler:

The New Radicals
Democrats need to be the uncompromising ones now.
Brian Beutler
Sep 30


Over the past year and a half I’ve warned promiscuously about the dangers of “funding Donald Trump’s government.” I’ve taken to referring to bipartisan spending bills, which have passed with Democrats casting decisive votes, as “enabling” legislation.

This language is provocative. It is meant to be provocative, in part because I want Democrats to think about their place in history right now. If democracy collapses or America becomes a pariah state, Republicans will be to blame, but people will ask, what did the rest of the society do to try and stop them?

But I also mean every word of it. I use all of that language advisedly. I understand that playing constitutional hardball can cause collateral damage. The Democratic Party has been pathologically averse to conflict with Republicans throughout the Trump era. But when, for instance, they tapped out of a government shutdown fight that they were winning, fear and neurosis weren’t the only factors. They were genuinely upset on behalf of federal workers, who were going without pay. They are bleeding-heart liberals in the earnest sense of the term. It’s Republicans who don’t give a shit about those people, which is why, until Trump came along, it was always Republicans who’d refuse to fund the government under Democratic presidents, and it was always Democrats inveighing against their tactics.

But Republicans weren’t just shutting down the government because they’re callous and sadistic (though they are both, and increasingly so). It was because they’d been radicalized against the government they were expected to fund.

I think the basis of their radicalization was completely insane. All radicalisms aren’t created equal. The Republican Party’s fanaticism makes it unique in the democratic world, even among far-right parties. But I do think it was genuine.

This piece is about two things: First, it’s about why constitutional hardball makes sense from the perspective of radicals. Second, a decade into the this era of rising Republican fascism and the corruption of the American state, it’s about why it’s time for the worm to turn—for Democrats to become the more radical of the two parties. And, in their case, for good reasons.

We wouldn’t be where we are if Republicans hadn’t radicalized against American democracy before Donald Trump took over their party.

This story begins over 90 years ago, with the enactment of New Deal. An alliance of wealthy interests and bigoted, paranoid right-wing fanatics, hated how Franklin Roosevelt had transformed the country. Together, from the jump, they plotted its destruction.

But in part because its earliest incarnations excluded black citizens, the new social compact was broadly popular. The nascent “conservative movement” was badly outnumbered.

As more and more kinds of people began benefiting from the welfare state, though, opposition to it grew and intensified. Whole political philosophies were developed or coopted to backstop and brand what was at bottom raw revanchism. This was not “conservatism” as most people used the term, and thus it remained a fringe formation for decades. But it began to metastasize.

Barry Goldwater helped consolidate it within the Republican Party. At first, it was just one faction. A minority partner. But over time its ranks swelled. In 1994, it became the GOP’s largest faction, and the whole party began behaving in more radical ways—mostly toward the end of undoing the New Deal. The modern era of lengthy government shutdowns and routine legislative hostage taking begins with Newt Gingrich. Under him, Republicans institutionalized “starve the beast”—the party’s strategic, lockstep opposition to tax increases—in order to create the fiscal pressure required to crush Medicare, Medicaid and Social Security.

Now, again, this is a crazy basis for reactionary politics. But if you are a prelapsarian weirdo who thinks American values were only truly and constitutionally expressed when the country was economically and racially segregated, and a small group of connected elites controlled the government—well, you probably find the post-war settlement pretty troubling. The leading legal lights of the movement would write about “restoring the lost Constitution,” and the “Constitution in exile.”

And if that’s what you’ve convinced yourself has happened—or if that’s what you at least claim to believe—radicalism makes perfect sense. As Goldwater said, “extremism in the defense of liberty is no vice.”

When people with that mindset took over the GOP, we were doomed to a lengthy, turbulent period of destabilizing attacks on modernity, and, eventually, democracy.

Together we can turn the tables on the democracy-hating reactionaries who’ve brought the country to the brink of ruin. But we need to link arms. And we need to convince Democrats to see things our way.

Unfortunately, Republicans lacked popular support for both their methods and their objectives.

When they’d shut down the government to take people’s health care away, the public would get mad at them and they had to back down. But they kept doing stuff like that, often in spite of themselves. Sometimes things just got out of hand. They couldn’t get their way holding the whole country hostage, but they could maybe force Democrats to blink by acting like feral animals. Republican leaders exploited this ambiguity routinely during the Obama years. Our members are crazy! They’ve taken over! They’ll do real damage unless you appease them. In 2011, that approach paid off handsomely. Between threatening to shut down the government and threatening to send the country into credit default, Republicans pocketed enormous, one-sided concessions from President Obama and congressional Democrats. A couple years later, when Obama refused to defund his signature health care law, they stumbled into a pointless shutdown more or less in spite of themselves.

Eventually Obama got wise. He refused in principle to negotiate with a gun to his head, and Republicans basically dropped the extortion tactic. But you can see why a president who takes the public’s wellbeing seriously might be inclined to placate the radicals.

Donald Trump does not take the public’s wellbeing seriously. He is unlikely to be head-faked into better behavior. But his abettors in Congress might bend to intense and growing public pressure to force him into line with the rule of law. My view in the second Trump presidency is that there is a now real and politically viable basis for radical action in America. By Democrats.


The term “enabling legislation” is meant to evoke Hitler’s transformation into a dictator. Not because I think Trump is Adolf Hitler (though he is capable of evil on that scale), but because the delegation of power Democrats have accepted is analogous to how Hitler consolidated his.

Trump has been breaking the law—including the budget law—on a daily basis, and in many ways, since his second presidency began. Providing Republicans the votes they need to help Trump get away with these abuses amounts to capitulation: You’re in charge, you can keep doing this stuff. Maybe in principle we’d like to stop you, but we’re not going to try. We’re going to resign ourselves to giving up our power.

Predictably, with each new grant of authority, Trump has grown more lawless. He has shuttered duly enacted federal agencies. His deportation regime combines Gestapo and Stasi tactics. He defies court orders. He steals appropriations earmarked for states that voted against him, then raids the fisc to build himself monuments and run propaganda advertisements on television. He launched a war against Iran. He trades stocks based on inside information, and sells the inside information to Wall Street. He’s pocketed billions of dollars in less than two years. Congress has abided it all; the courts have abided most of it.

When I write that Democrats shouldn’t fund Trump’s government until the law-breaking ends, I use the term “Trump’s government” not in the nature of partisan spin, but because, under Trump, the government is rogue. The Constitution is in exile.


And so 15 years later my view is that Democrats should conduct themselves a bit like Republicans did in Obama’s first term.

Not exactly like Republicans, not to spurious or non-germane ends. But with the same kind of radical fervor, on behalf of values the public supports.

The biggest difference is that Obama was not an aspiring dictator, and there was no sense in which funding the government was funding his government, or enabling his lawlessness. To non-ideologues, Republicans seemed in thrall to a quixotic fervor. The public may have wanted them to break the Democratic lock on power, and even attempt to do unwise things, like cut deficits in aftermath of a deep recession. They didn’t want them to behave like saboteurs.

In 2011, they mugged Obama with a bunch of random policy demands in exchange for their votes to fund the government. The goal was to make his presidency a slog, pick his pocket, as much as to vindicate any deeply held principles.

I don’t believe Democrats should do this. I don’t believe they should deny their votes for appropriations in exchange for, e.g., restoring abortion rights or settling long-run health-policy debates.

But they should refuse to fund illegal activity—the war in Iran, routine due-process violations, violations of the Hatch Act. And they should certainly refuse to strike any budget deal with Trump so long as he means to violate it—by unilaterally defunding agencies, withholding disaster relief and federal grants to blue states, or any other means.

If Trump wants to insist on the right to make unilateral war, and spend tax dollars on campaign aids, and otherwise govern like a king, such that he will veto a budget that requires him to faithfully execute the laws, let him shut down his own government.

Democrats should enumerate these kinds of conditions if and when they win the election, and they should enter negotiations acting like they mean it. No unconditional funds. No long-term budgets that make if impossible to enforce compliance for months and months at a time.

This should be their posture because it is righteous. It’s also very likely that—in contrast to 2011 and 2013, when the public rejected Republican constitutional hardball—Americans will side with Democrats. They know that what’s happening is wrong. When Democrats shut down the government last year, demanding an extension of expiring health-insurance subsidies, the public supported them and blamed Republicans for the shutdown. Will voters suddenly decide they’re okay with the Iran war if Democrats insist on defunding it?

It would also be good practice for the fights of the post-Trump era.

Much as Trump pretends to support Social Security and Medicare, he and Republicans have done grievous damage to public finance. The fiscal pressure on those programs is suddenly quite severe, and we should count on Republicans to re-embrace “starve the beast” tactics once Trump is gone. If Democrats are radicalized as they should be, they will insist on easing the pressure exclusively with new taxes on wealthy Americans and big corporations—the only real winners in the Trump regime.

Or, Democrats can maintain their current paper-tiger posture. Trump will smell weakness. He’ll refuse to concede anything—at least anything enforceable. He’ll get funding for his lawless regime, while rejecting all oversight requests out of hand. Democrats will have surrendered their recourse, and the grassroots rebellion against the party establishment will continue.

56 Comments
cleek
cleek
1 month ago

Will voters suddenly decide they’re okay with the Iran war if Democrats insist on defunding it?

Republicans will, of course. they will immediately start accusing Dems of trying to appease Iran.

what remains to be seen is how the media covers that. will they start asking Dems “why do you love Iran?” or will they say cautious things like “a bare majority of Americans agree the war was a mistake but don’t want to defund the troops or give in to Tehran’s demands”

there is no third option.

Last edited 1 month ago by cleek
wjca
wjca
1 month ago

The Republican Party’s fanaticism makes it unique in the democratic world, even among far-right parties. 

…

this is a crazy basis for reactionary politics. But if you are a prelapsarian weirdo who thinks American values were only truly and constitutionally expressed when the country was economically and racially segregated, and a small group of connected elites controlled.

The difference between us and other countries with far-right parties, I think, is that ours comes with a massive dose of libertarianism.

The sources are various. Those who profit more when the government cannot constrain their corporations on behalf of the public good have an obvious reason, but there just aren’t that many of them. Which is why we saw things like the Progressive movement after the 19th century Gilded Age.

What made the libertarian view spread widely is that it attracted those whose only real devotion to libertarian philosophy was not wanting the government to constrain their racism. Which is to say, they were (in many cases still are) fine with economic populism, as long as it isn’t inhibiting their racism. FDR didn’t upset them that much, because he wasn’t focused on attacking Jim Crow.

In both cases, they “remember” an idealized time when government didn’t stop them. And then, a lot of unrelated cultural baggage from that time gets folded in. Not least because it allows them to attract people with a romantic vision of the 19th century and the open frontier, without the basis that actually motivates the other two groups.

nous
nous
1 month ago

Quick note between the end of today’s office hours and having to go to class…

I’ve started teaching that bicycle advocacy (research writing) class that I mentioned a while back, and so far it seems to be going better than I had expected. There’s a lot of reading (by their standards, not mine) but they seem to be really interested in the ideas and excited by the way that the author is taking things that matter to her and arguing powerfully and persuasively. I think this is going to work.

As for my own bike riding, I’m making it farther now, but still not yet up to anything like the length of my previous rides, and no sniff of trails yet. In the months before the crash I had been thinking about the sort of bike I would build for myself if I were trying to make an ideal ride-anywhere/maintain-easily bike for myself. I was seriously considering the use of mechanical disk brakes – requires more grip effort but are less fussy and easier to maintain than hydraulic disk brakes. I’m pretty firmly in the hydraulic camp at the moment due to reduced grip strength and minor pain.

I told my students last class that adaptive cycling is a good subject for research if anyone was interested. Not all bodies can ride all bikes, and any of us might find ourselves joining the ranks of the excluded in an instant if our circumstances lean that way.

I’m not feeling bad about the midterms mainly because we won’t know until they happen just how far the GOP is going to push to try to prevent serious losses, and we can’t know that until it happens. All we can do is prepare for disruptions and be prepared to adapt and respond with purpose. That’s where I am.

hairshirthedonist
hairshirthedonist
1 month ago

I love this.

https://ca.news.yahoo.com/trump-says-regrets-nominating-supreme-123634128.html

“I ​do like loyalty, yeah,” Trump ‌told the interviewer, who then asked whether that was what he wanted from the justices.

“No, I don’t want loyalty. I want good decisions,” Trump said.

Except, to him, good decisions are decisions he likes, law notwithstanding, so it ends up the same either way.

russell
russell
1 month ago

The United States is a very large country containing a really broad range of cultures, traditions, etc. New York is not Abilene, Portland is not Tallahassee, etc.

The argument here is that (D)’s should have taken a harder line with Trump, and specifically refused to approve money for a variety of crappy (or mostly, or partly) crappy things.

That would be popular in some places and would not in others.

This piece kind of strikes me as the flip side of all the people freaking out about Mamdani and AOC (and formerly Bernie). Instead of “(D)’s are too radical” the argument here is “(D)’s aren’t radical enough”.

Mamdani is a great mayor for NYC. AOC is a great House rep for Queens and the Bronx, which are about the most diverse communities in the country.

John Tester was a great Senator for Montana. Spanberger was a great House rep for VA-7, and looks to be a great governor for VA.

These people are all pretty different on specific policies. What they have in common, and what is distinctive about the (D)’s and has been since FDR at least, is the idea that it is legitimate for government to do things to improve people’s lives. As in, directly, through the provision of public goods of various kinds.

Since at least the 60’s and especially since Reagan, (R)’s have hated all of that. Cripple government, make it as small as possible, clear the way for people who want to make eleventy billion dollars in whatever way to do so with the least possible interference from the public sector.

(R)’s stand for, and fight for, the rights of property. (D)’s stand for, and fight for, the rights of people.

That is the difference. That is what needs to be called out.

What that looks like on the ground is gonna be very different in different places, but the basic orientation of the two parties is pretty consistently as I’ve described, obviously IMO.

“Radical” doesn’t fly everywhere. “You are actually helping me” does.

Last edited 1 month ago by Russell Lane
hairshirthedonist
hairshirthedonist
1 month ago

Is it just me or do a lot of these pundit-strategists talk as though everyone is running for president?

nous
nous
1 month ago

I agree with you here, russell. If I were to try to paraphrase what I think Beutler is trying to advocate for here, though, it would not be for them to take more bold and radical action, so much as to refuse to be conciliatory out of fear of being portrayed as radicals. The Republicans have trashed checks and balances and are giving the president a pass to do things that are illegal and unconstitutional. Shut it down if you can, and when the press tries to do its usual job of both-siding and treating Republicans’ bad faith justifications as serious propositions, call them out for being naive and cowardly.

I don’t mind if Democrats yell at each other over policy and political philosophy on the road to legislative decisions, but they definitely should not be lending their votes to anything that undermines voting rights or due process. And if you do end up voting to approve a budget extension after a shutdown, make sure to say that the Republicans were willing to starve your constituents or take their homes from them in order to get their own (insert radical and unconstitutional thing) pushed through.

And if the press continues to try to appear neutral and carry water for that crap after you lay things out clearly, you hammer them for being subservient, and you keep doing it until that point sticks, the same way that the right did with their mainstream media bias bullshit for forty years.

Both moderate centrist Democrats and populist social Democrats can do this while holding firm to their own principles and beliefs. All that they would be doing is standing up for the actual constitution and rule of law as it was before the GOP and their activist judges decided to ignore the constitution for the sake of a radical wishlist of policy grabs that harm anyone not in their country club.

And whatever the fuck you do, don’t let Chuck Schumer be the spokesperson for any of this. He absolutely sucks at throwing a verbal punch.

cleek
cleek
1 month ago

>Is it just me or do a lot of these pundit-strategists talk as though everyone is running for president?

oh indeed. the political press loves nothing more than a horserace.

Pro Bono
Pro Bono
1 month ago

Adaptive cycling: I’m doing that, in a small way. I used to be a fairly serious road cyclist – up to 200 miles a week in summer. Now my neck can’t take it. I’ve had surgery, but realistically I’m not going to be able to ride a road bike in comfort again. Never mind, I’ve bought a bicycle I can ride sitting up, I get around town on it, and do my grocery shopping. One’s horizons narrow, but everything is relative.

nous
nous
1 month ago

I’m waiting a while before I start thinking about changing my bicycle’s cockpit around. I can tell when I grip the handlebars on my eMTB that it is the thing I was holding when my thumb broke. Bars with a little bit more backsweep engage the muscles in my hand differently and relieve some of the ache that will linger until the sprains heal fully.

Am becoming very aware, also, how many assumptions about bike use are built into the specifications. The eMTB has a 35mm diameter stem clamp because it assumes that the combination of a 40 lb. bike and rugged trail use demand a stiffer, stronger set of handlebars, but all of the handlebars with more backsweep assume a 31.8 mm diameter stem clamp to allow the bars to flex a bit for comfort. That’s the other reason to hold off on changes – multiple contingencies.

It’ll all get sorted out eventually.

`wonkie
`wonkie
1 month ago

Tammy Duckworth said that she is tired of Dems having to fix Republican shit. I am too, and I am also tired of voters electing Republicans after the Dems have fixed the Republican shit.

Dems do believe in public service and a majority of voters have shown repeatedly that once they feel served, they will vote R because they want services only for themselves.

What we are seeing this fall isn’t a repudiation of Republicans or their core values (selfishness and racism). It’s a lot of Republican voters who are thinking, “Wait! What? Trump screwed ME? He was supposed to screw those other people!”
Once Dems fix things again those people will revert and start voting R again.

How do we break this cycle? Ruthless power-seeking: voting representation in Congress for DC, reform the Supreme Court until the conservatives are a minority, anti-gerrymandering and other voting rights legislation, anti-Citizens United legislation, break up the media monopolies.

Doing good for the voters is a good thing to do but don’t expect any result except to elect Republicans as soon as the former R voters feel comfortable again.

GftNC
GftNC
1 month ago

There’s a lot to what wonkie says. Meanwhile, below is John Light today. I would give almost anything for Angie Nixon to win. There are no words blistering enough to describe Vance’s naked, amoral emptiness of character; I feel that with X-ray vision one would perceive inside him an enormous, empty black hole.

THE BRIEF
JD Vance Says Black, Socialist Candidate for Senate Doesn’t ‘Belong in America’
By John Light | 10.02.26

LAKELAND, FLORIDA – OCTOBER 1: U.S. Vice President JD Vance speaks during a midterm campaign rally to support Republican gubernatorial candidate Rep. Byron Donalds (R-FL) on October 1, 2026 in Lakeland, Florida. Vance is campaigning around the country in the run-up to the Novemnber 3 midterm elections. (Photo by Kevin Lamarque-Pool/Getty Images)

A New Chapter in Vance’s Effort to Police Who’s American
JD Vance visited Florida yesterday, stumping for candidates in races that for a few cycles have been safely red. Among them was Republicans’ candidate for U.S. Senate, Ashley Moody, who was appointed by governor Ron DeSantis (R) to replace Secretary of State Marco Rubio and is now running for reelection against Angie Nixon, a Florida state legislator. Nixon is a member of the Democratic Socialists of America who won a surprise primary victory over Trump impeachment figure Alexander Vindman.

As Vance attacked Nixon, he cast her as a dangerous radical. “When Angie Nixon calls herself a socialist, I think the right response is to say, ‘Then get the hell out of here. You don’t belong in America,’” the vice president declared. The crowd cheered.

Nixon responded swiftly.

“The most ordinary man imaginable came to my home state to tell me to ‘get out of America’ while they enjoyed the comfort of buildings my ancestors built,” she wrote on social media. “Imagine standing on the shoulders of the ppl who built this country & then telling their descendants they don’t belong here,” said Nixon, who is Black.

“Wanting lower property insurance & healthcare for families isn’t un-American; it’s what working people deserve,” she continued. “They can take their tech-bro cash and their weird, intrusive agenda somewhere else, because I’m not going any damn place.”

Recent polls in Florida have shown Nixon running behind Moody, and Democrats’ candidate for Florida governor, David Jolly, neck-in-neck with Trump-endorsed gubernatorial candidate Rep. Byron Donalds (R). Trump won Florida in 2024 by 13 points. Vance’s remarks Thursday were in Polk County, a reliable MAGA stronghold.

Vance, who, famously, once mused about whether Trump was merely a “cynical asshole like Nixon who wouldn’t be that bad (and might even prove useful)” or “America’s Hitler,” has attempted a reinvention as a kind of MAGA intellectual. A key aspect of that has been policing who is truly American. He devoted much of his speech at Republicans’ midterm convention to discussing his view of the American “birthright,” and has articulated the idea that those whose ancestors have been in America for longer have greater claim to it.

Defining Americanism by its idealistic principals alone would “reject a lot of people that the ADL would label as domestic extremists, even though those very Americans had their ancestors fight in the Revolutionary War and the Civil War,” he said in a 2024 speech to the Claremont Institute, referencing the Anti-Defamation League, a nonprofit that as part of its work spreads information about hate groups.

“I think the people whose ancestors fought in the Civil War have a hell of a lot more claim over America than the people who say they don’t belong,” he added, seeming to suggest that peddlers of hate are more American than members of a group, founded by Jews to fight antisemitism, that denounces them.

`wonkie
`wonkie
1 month ago

This guy, who has status and influence, is nothing but a hater of anyone not of northern European ancestry. The reason Republicans get a base of thirty percent of the voters no matter how badly they fuck things up plus another ten to fifteen is they appeal to the fear of the Other. That’s a terrible reflection on the character of America but Othering–often institutionalized—has always been a big part of our history. Given the structure of the Senate the haters, even when down to the Crazification Factor, are still over or nearly half of the Senate.
Doing good will not keep these people at bay. Climate change might, though.
The one thing that unites Americans is the belief that the government is supposed to save them in time of need. We are on the brink of things getting so fucked up that even some of the Crazification Factor will be desperate. (It’s a myth that Trump represented “left out and left behind voters btw. He represents overrepresented voters who for the most part were doing okay before he fucked them over.)
The need for FEMA, food costs supports, supports for farmers, cheaper household energy, access to water etc is going to make it harder for Republicans to run for office on fear of trans kids and drag queens, tho I expect fear of Black people will remain effective in many places.
On the other hand, things falling apart might trigger an all out fascist response as the white Republican base tries to grab all of the remaining safety and throw everyone else under the bus.
My dad said that he thought FDR saved the US from a revolution. So which way will it go for us? Will economic collapse from climate change lead for a demand for government that serves the people or for a demand for government that serve Republican voters and no one else?

`wonkie
`wonkie
1 month ago
nous
nous
1 month ago

wonkie – are you talking about Rufo, Keeperman, or “yes?”

Keeperman, is definitely a person in the mold of JD Vance. He’s ambitious, articulate, and utterly without scruples in service to that ambition, willing to throw purported friends and associates to the wolves if it gets him a bigger audience, more influence, and material reward. It’s a marker of how utterly shallow the US conservative movement is that he’s climbed his way into the spotlight because he’s an edgelord poser who only stepped into the light when the Guardian forced him into it by taking away his anonymity. His intellectual positions are all just white power and manosphere whining repackaged with an MFA writer’s glowup. Strip it of the pretty language and its the usual insecure drivel from a little boy who resents having to treat women and minorities as equals.

Like Vance, he’s willing to twist and reinvent himself in order to become a pet intellectual for the white nationalist billionaire class, and he’ll betray friends to slip inside that bubble.

russell
russell
1 month ago

Rufo is an Italian name. Rufo’s people, at least those of Rufo’s people who carried that name, have probably been in the country for about 100 years, 150 years maximum.

For the first few decades they were here, they were not generally considered to really be “American”. Catholics, garlic eaters, swarthy. When my wife was growing up in the 60’s her parents didn’t want her to date an Italian guy who was interested in her because (a) Catholic and (b) everyone knows Italians beat their wives.

Keeperman is Jewish. Nuff said.

These guys have very very very short memories.

The whole “heritage American” thing is utter bullshit. Indigenous people were here first, like for thousands of years first. Spanish-speaking people have been living in what is now the United States for centuries before any English-speaking settlement happened. French-speaking people were in what is now northern New England a decade before any permanent English-speaking settlement. A broad swath of the country from Pennsylvania through Ohio and into the Midwest is largely populated by people whose folks came from Germany and German was as commonly spoken as English throughout that area.

Then the Irish and Chinese, then the eastern and southern Europeans, then nobody but northern Europeans for a while, then southeast Asians after Vietnam. Now South Americans and Haitians after their countries imploded in no small part to our history of f***ing with them. And Afghans and other folks fleeing the wars we visited upon them.

If we really want to get down to it, other than folks whose people came over on the freaking Mayflower, the people whose family history here most likely goes right back to the beginning are African Americans, who have been here since 1619.

And I’m leaving aside all the lily-white “heritage settlers” who came here as an alternative to prison or the noose.

The United States is and has been for centuries an ethnic salmagundi. Every new group that arrives is viewed as foreign, weird, and threatening by xenophobic @ssholes. Then their kids and grandkids assimilate and nobody cares that much anymore.

Rufo and Keeperman are the @ssholes of today, and Vance is their pimp.

Michael Cain
Michael Cain
1 month ago

My dad said that he thought FDR saved the US from a revolution.

When I was a kid I could occasionally get my tiny-town Iowa grandfather to tell me Depression stories. He told me about the Communists and the Nazis alternating at the Grange Hall on Saturday evenings, both advocating for the violent overthrow of the federal government. He always said they both got respectful listenings, and there were plenty of people ready to grab their rifles and go. He and Grandma spoke about FDR like he was a saint.

Most people forget that the “Roaring 20’s” was an almost exclusively urban thing. By the time the stock-market crash rolled around, rural America had been in a deep recession since shortly after the end of WWI.

Michael Cain
Michael Cain
1 month ago

When I was a kid I could occasionally get my tiny-town Iowa grandfather to tell me Depression stories.

One I had to dig out from other people… One summer when I was a kid in the mid-1960s — so 12, maybe 13 — we made a weekend trip to my grandparents at an usual time of year (ie, not a holiday). Nothing special seemed to be going on, except that a large number of people my grandfather’s age or older stopped by the house, talked quietly to him, shook his hand. (Some women hugged him and Grandma didn’t complain.) Turned out that during the Depression he could take on debt because he owned a working business: the local grocery. During the Depression he took barter, and put things on tabs that he knew would never be repaid, but kept people from starving. We were there because after 30 years he had finally paid off all of the Depression-era debt he had taken on, and the community wanted a chance to say thank you. (Grandpa would never have let them do something public.)

GftNC
GftNC
1 month ago

That’s a great story, Michael. Your grandfather sounds like a wonderful man. I’m guessing that these people who talk about “real Americans” never think about people like that. Too bad, they really should, they need to be reminded.

Nooneithinkisinmytree
Nooneithinkisinmytree
1 month ago

The US Post Office will run out of funds before the election and all mail delivery will be halted.

That’s the plan.

What comes after will look like the abattoirs of the Balkans, the Congo, and the Rape of Nanking.

nous
nous
1 month ago

This one seems a good fit for this place- a Guardian piece that parallels Burnham’s critique of the Thatcher Era with the rise and fall of Manchester City FC:

https://www.theguardian.com/news/ng-interactive/2026/oct/03/manchester-city-guilty-verdict-football

The whole situation with Man City really highlights the reasons why I lost interest in elite football* (soccer), and have been drawn to professional women’s sports. It’s not that women’s pro sports don’t have the same potential problems with money and ownership, it’s that the athletes themselves are still being paid on a scale that keeps them more proletarian and closer to the fans – especially the young girls who look up to them.

*I’ve never been much of an English football fan. I preferred the style of play in the Bundesliga, but got tired of watching my FC Bayern bully the other clubs financially, so the City mess resonates with me.

GftNC
GftNC
1 month ago

Oh boy, here we go, also from John Light, today (I know many of you get TPM, but for those who don’t):

Georgia Election Board Employee Allegedly Goes Rogue, Requests Federal Intervention

Last week, a letter surfaced from the Georgia Election Board, signed by board executive director James Mills, requesting that the federal government intervene in his state’s election. Addressed to attorney general Todd Blanche and cc-ing Assistant Attorney General for Civil Rights Harmeet Dhillon and Secretary of Homeland Security Markwayne Mullin, the letter asked that the agencies get involved with and oversee numerous aspects of Georgia’s 2026 election.

Secretary of State Brad Raffensperger’s office denounced the latter. “People who are serious about election security don’t inject chaos in the eleventh hour,” a Raffensperge spokesperson told MS NOW.

Then, over the weekend, the story got weirder: Members of the state election board alleged that Mills never was authorized by the board to send the letter, and was essentially using his position to freelance ahead of the election.

“We have no control over our executive director, and he does whatever the hell he wants to,” the chair of the board, John Fervier, told reporter Jessica Huseman, who broke that aspect of the story for Votebeat.

The five-member Georgia Election Board, readers may remember, was restructured in 2023 to provide Republicans with a significant majority. President Trump has praised various members of that majority, who have entertained conspiracy theories about the way in which the state conducts its elections. A year before the DOJ launched its own investigation of the 2020 election in Fulton County, the Georgia Election Board ordered its own.

Fervier, the chair who accused Mills of freelancing, is a Republican but has frequently clashed with his three Republican colleagues on the board and isntead voted with its sole Democrat. He’s also clashed — sometimes very publicly — with Mills, who was hired by the board but is not on the board.

Another Republican member of the board also expressed displeasure with Mills to Votebeat’s Huseman, saying that, though this letter may have been inspired by a resolution the board voted on that urged Raffensperger’s office to begin software updates for voting machines and empowered Mills to seek federal help around those updates, Mills’ requests to the DOJ and DHS went far beyond that. That member, Salleigh Grubbs, also said board members were not given a chance to review Mills’ letter.

“In private enterprise, if I told an employee I wanted to see something before it goes and he did this, we’d be having a very different conversation,” Grubbs said. “I thought we were all on the same team.”

This mess is kind of funny, but also very serious. More broadly, this is the kind of thing we should expect heading into the midterms — an official, and perhaps not even an important official, acting on their own to encourage the Trump administration to get involved in an election and take sweeping action. The DOJ and DHS have not yet responded in any public way to Mills, but the administration has valorized similar figures who have gone rogue, such as former Mesa County, Colorado Clerk Tina Peters. Requests like Mills’ give the DOJ material to spin into whatever narrative it wants.

Michael Cain
Michael Cain
1 month ago

The US Post Office will run out of funds before the election and all mail delivery will be halted.

My ballot arrived in my mailbox today, a day earlier than I anticipated from the “your ballot has been mailed” notice. Also the county booklet explaining the 12 local initiatives (to go with the 14 statewide initiatives). Few of the local initiatives apply to me.

The one I have to spend some time thinking about is the new 0.33% sales tax to fund rail transit running from Fort Collins to Colorado Springs (about 120 miles). Service wouldn’t start until 2029, and I’m not sure it will run often enough to entice me to downtown Denver, but it’s the first time the feds have agreed to break the stranglehold the rail companies hold on rights-of-way and crossing priority dating back to the 1870s. (Don’t get me started on how those have survived all of those companies being granted Chapter 11 bankruptcy multiple times.)

nous
nous
1 month ago

Michael – It was my understanding that the rail service from Fort Collins to Denver was already scheduled to roll out and was paid for, and the additional tax was to cover the southward expansion to Colorado Springs. Am I mistaken?

(Been following this because the in-laws are in the Springs and could use us being closer – but being in So Cal I don’t have the benefit of any local coverage interested in the details. Would like to know more. Daily trains from Denver to the Springs would open up more real estate options for us.)

wjca
wjca
1 month ago

How I can tell that I live in a bubble:

My town puts out a quarterly newsletter. The fall edition includes a variety of statistics on what’s been happening. Recreation & Community Services, Development, Maintenance, and Public Safety.

One really caught my eye:
Vehicle thefts solved: 58% (vs a national average of 9.3%)
Burglary cases solved: 48% (vs a national average of 13%)

I look at those national averages, and I think: Wow, no wonder people think there’s a crime problem. Maybe it’s not so much how many crimes occur as the absolutely minscule fraction which get solved. And those are the types of crimes people are most likely to be victims of.

Michael Cain
Michael Cain
1 month ago

@nous, you’re right. They have money in hand for track improvements, stations, and rolling stock for the Fort Collins to Union Station route. That said, I’m not confident about the actual operations until they have a dedicated tax stream, and whether Amtrak (who will operate the route) will be fare- and frequency-competitive with the current luxury bus service ($7.50 one-way for an old, and several departures each day). The rail service will have more stops and a longer average trip time.

Michael Cain
Michael Cain
1 month ago

Once upon a time I mentioned that I was going to eventually look at some of the AI (substitute “trained neural network” wherever I use that) software for image enhancement. expressed an interest in what the results were like.

My daughter is arranging a small memorial service for my late wife through the funeral home. One of the things that comes with the package is a print-on-canvas portrait. My daughter wanted the picture to be from while my wife was in memory care and provided some for me to choose from. All of them were shots with one or more other family members. I chose the one I thought was most flattering and cut out an image with just my wife. Size in pixels is 715×1061. The image for the canvas print needs to be much higher resolution than that.

So, I ran the image through Topaz Labs’ 4x AI up-sampler (yielding 2860×4244 pixels). I ran that result through Adobe’s free AI background remover, then composited that on top of a free background from Unsplash. The image below shows the original small picture in the upper-left on top of the processed image. The processed image is remarkably free of artifacts. Bear in mind that effectively, 15 of every 16 pixels in that image are “hallucinations”, as they say — sh*t the software made up. The Adobe software did a very good foreground/background separation, correctly classifying individual hair strands. Both AI operations were done in the cloud and took several minutes.

In theory you can click on the image and get the full-size .jpg image. Can’t guarantee that, because WordPress :^)

testing
CharlesWT
CharlesWT
1 month ago

Nano-Banana-2 on the Poe platform created this image. It’s not an image enhancement. It’s a new image using the original image as a reference with a text prompt.

Link: Photorealistic Portrait Conversion

Michael_Cain-wife-3
wjca
wjca
1 month ago

Thank you, Michael