First and Last men

by liberal japonicus

I’ve never had much time for Francis Fukuyama, I felt like his thesis about the End of History was warmed over Hegel, and I never really registered him as a Japanese-American, so this Ones and Tooze podcast was quite interesting to me.

Tooze discusses how Fukuyama’s personal history influenced his intellectual development and despite finding myself on the opposite side of almost all of his work, I feel I have a bit of insight into who Fukuyama is. Hope you can bear with me while I give a quick summary of Fukuyama’s background and trajectory and why I might momentarily entertain this.

Fukuyama was born in 1952 and is, like me, a third generation Japanese-American (sansei) 1952 is on the early side for a sansei, I was born in the early 60’s so there is a 10 year difference and I was born to a father who was the 7th child but there are similarities. His grandfather, like mine, emigrated to avoid conscription. His (second generation) father was Yoshio Fukuyama, who got his doctorate from U of Chicago and was a faculty member at Chicago Theological Seminary, which, if you check it out, is pretty firmly in the tradition of leftist activism. This substack essay, (which I find problematic) while concentrating on Francis, tries to link his father to the whole UofC school of economics, missing the fact that Fukuyama pere got his doctorate in the Sociology department, which is the complete inverse of the Econ department. Tooze notes the elder Fukuyama must have been shocked at what his son got up to, though I don’t know if that is from the memoir or not.

As Wikipedia notes, he grew up in Manhattan, and had little contact with Japanese culture, and the given name of Francis suggests that this wasn’t a conscious choice, but an assimilation urge expressed in raising him. This also tracks with me, my father really had no interest in Japan until I came here to work. Tooze goes thru the younger Fukuyama’s intellectual influences, starting with Allan Bloom. and I was quite surprised to learn that Fukuyama had an initial idea to go into comparative literature, starting at Yale and then going to Paris to study with Derrida and Barthes. (I also entertained thoughts of comp lit, and went to France, but I went as an assistant des langue) This seems like another shared point, and I’d suggest that both Fukuyama and I, and maybe a lot of sansei, while not rejecting Japan and Japanese culture, feel the pull of the West.

But comp lit (and French strucuturalism) didn’t really suit him, and he moved to political science, studying with Huntington, doing his PhD on Soviet threats and ending up at the Rand Corporation. I, on the other hand, ended up going back to the US and then joined the JET program, which basically determined my course in life.

So I’d suggest that both Fukuyama and I have been really drawn to a Euro centric view of the world. As I said, he’s got a Hegelian take on things and the book that put him in wider view was entitled The End of History and the Last Man, and the memoir discussed in the podcast has the title In the Realm of the Last Man: A Memoir, are both from Nietzsche’s concept of der letzte Mensch. I see an interesting opposition between that and the title of Camus’ unfinished memoir The First Man (Le Premier Homme), and I feel lucky that I was pulled into Existentialism and the notion of Absurdist Self-Creation. But that desire to navigate the West seems to be shared.

Tooze also notes that Fukuyama’s memoir describes how Fukuyama was pulled along by the people around him and he is intellectually honest enough to note that with a different group of mentors and colleagues, his intellectual path would have been different and it’s a thought that I often have. I feel that I have been pulled along by the group I was in and with a different group, I would have been in a different place. Tooze also mentions that Fukuyama also spends a lot of time talking about thymos or the inherent need to be recognized by others, which was also discussed in his first book, so I’m interested to see how Fukuyama discusses his own thymos and how that may inform his first book.

This might just be my apophenic tendencies, so feel free to weigh in.

4 Comments
novakant
novakant
1 month ago

<i>I was quite surprised to learn that Fukuyama had an initial idea to go into comparative literature, starting at Yale and then going to Paris to study with Derrida and Barthes.</i>

Make that two. I never read his famous book, but then I have an inkling that I am not alone in that. It’s one of those much talked about and little read books. I read some interviews promoting his memoir in which he tries to set the record straight. I found it interesting how an idea can be ‘misunderstood’ for decades due to laziness, opportunism or willful ignorance.

novakant
novakant
1 month ago

PS I will, however, maintain that he was wrong on postmodernism, if I understand him correctly, and counter with something along the lines of Rorty (whom I have read).

nous
nous
1 month ago

Dammit, now I feel like I have to go read Derrida’s Specters of Marx. To be fair, it’s probably time. I’ve downloaded it from the Uni library. Prediction markets are now open for how far I get with this.

Interesting isomorphism to consider here – Fukiyama as sansei born in the penumbra of WWII and the umbra of the Cold War vs. Derrida as a Jewish Pied Noir who went through lycee during the Vichy government and started his university years in the span of year above between World War and Cold War. What a rich and diverse set of outsider perspectives that makes for, landing on some of the most fraught identities of the aftermath of WWII.

In passing, I feel as if I have lived through Specters of Derrida in much the same way that Derrida describes the haunted nature of Marxism after 1989. I started my studies at UC Irvine the month before Derrida passed, and there was a palpable sense of him being physically absent, but psychically present in all of the Comp Lit/Critical Theory community functions. It was a weird moment for a non-traditional student like me to be initiated into and professionalized in the field.

Last edited 1 month ago by nous