Firstly, the essay GftNC linked above is really and expresses pretty much my view on the matter:
What the Public Memory of Charlie Kirk Revealed
For those who felt denigrated by his rhetoric, the bipartisan tributes to him as a champion of free speech augured something dangerous: the mainstreaming of formerly extremist views.
Secondly, I have started working at a school recently and I wonder more and more what this mainstreaming of extremism will do to our kids one day - to those who will be victims, to those who will just live in a world with different values than previously accepted and to those who will be perpetrators. This reactionary hate speech Kirk peddled is just diametrically opposed to any humanism and basic decency. Basically we spend half the day in one form or another telling kids to show respect and empathy for others and maybe some manners. And then these crazy people come along telling everyone the opposite is true:
You can tell the pupil sitting next to you she's stupid because she's black and her mother only got that job because she's black. You can crash the LGBT meeting and tell them they are disgusting child molesters. You can tell the Jewish boy that he's part of a vast conspiracy to rule the world and subdue the white race. You can tell the girls they are inferior, cannot get an abortion under ny cricumstances and have to submit to their husbands. You can tell the boy from Sudan, Ukraine, Mexico or wherever that he and his family are disgusting parasites feeding on the body of white America.
And then Klein tells us that we should somehow get onboard with all this because the Overton window has shifted and we have to embrace some weird version of doublethink. Let's just ditch all the values people have thought about and fought for hundreds of years and move to the ever rightward drifting "center". I rather think it's time for a "have you no decency" moment (though that was actually staged ... but pretty well).
Firstly, the essay GftNC linked above is really and expresses pretty much my view on the matter:
What the Public Memory of Charlie Kirk Revealed
For those who felt denigrated by his rhetoric, the bipartisan tributes to him as a champion of free speech augured something dangerous: the mainstreaming of formerly extremist views.
https://www.nytimes.com/2025/09/28/magazine/charlie-kirk-rhetoric.html?unlocked_article_code=1.pU8.E_Qk.vE_VAYwg6Chi&smid=url-share
Secondly, I have started working at a school recently and I wonder more and more what this mainstreaming of extremism will do to our kids one day - to those who will be victims, to those who will just live in a world with different values than previously accepted and to those who will be perpetrators. This reactionary hate speech Kirk peddled is just diametrically opposed to any humanism and basic decency. Basically we spend half the day in one form or another telling kids to show respect and empathy for others and maybe some manners. And then these crazy people come along telling everyone the opposite is true:
You can tell the pupil sitting next to you she's stupid because she's black and her mother only got that job because she's black. You can crash the LGBT meeting and tell them they are disgusting child molesters. You can tell the Jewish boy that he's part of a vast conspiracy to rule the world and subdue the white race. You can tell the girls they are inferior, cannot get an abortion under ny cricumstances and have to submit to their husbands. You can tell the boy from Sudan, Ukraine, Mexico or wherever that he and his family are disgusting parasites feeding on the body of white America.
And then Klein tells us that we should somehow get onboard with all this because the Overton window has shifted and we have to embrace some weird version of doublethink. Let's just ditch all the values people have thought about and fought for hundreds of years and move to the ever rightward drifting "center". I rather think it's time for a "have you no decency" moment (though that was actually staged ... but pretty well).
/rant